‘Rights and privileges’ supplant cooperation

Pastor Julie Pennington-Russell told me she found a FedEx package from the Georgia Baptist Convention (GBC) when she arrived at the First Baptist Church of Decatur, Ga., yesterday. It contained a letter from GBC Executive Director J. Robert White, the mouthpiece of the fundamentalist-controlled network of churches, informing her that the congregation’s relationship with the convention has been terminated.

She read the letter to the Decatur congregation at the conclusion of both morning services. She noted that her doctoral work is not yet complete, but she appreciates the confidence.

The letter read:

Dear Dr. Pennington-Russell-

The following recommendation from the Executive committee of the Georgia Baptist Convention was approved by messengers of the Georgia Baptist Convention in annual Session on November 10, 2009:

“That First Baptist Church of Decatur is not a cooperating church as defined in Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution because a woman is serving as senior pastor and that First Baptist Church of Decatur be excluded from the convention and all rights and privileges thereof.”

As indicated in my letter of November 2, 2009, funds received by the Convention from First Baptist Church of Decatur during 2009 will be returned.

I would be remiss if I did not say on behalf of the Convention how grateful we have been across many years of partnership with First Baptist of Decatur for our service and ministry together. You and the church family are in my thoughts and prayers today as you move forward to continue your ministry in the name of the Lord. We recognize and appreciate the faithfulness of First Baptist Church of Decatur throughout the years.


J. Robert White

No, White and other GBC leaders are remiss in their profound failure to understand and appreciate the long-held Baptist principle of local church autonomy and the long-term consequences of their onward march toward irrelevance.

The Decatur church is doing just fine — perhaps better — outside the unhealthy relationship with such a systemically ill organization. One could only hope that more congregations could make that discovery on their own.

Bob’s comment that the Decatur congregation — that considers Julie’s call a clear leading of the Spirit — is “excluded from the convention and all rights and privileges thereof” reveals just how the Boy’s Clubhouse continues to misunderstand the very reason for the convention’s existence.

The purpose of such Baptist organizations is to provide a means by which congregations can work together effectively in missions and ministry. It is about cooperation, not who has “rights and privileges.”

Well, it should be.


  1. The great irony here is that the Georgia Southern Baptists do not consider this congregation worthy of their cooperation and yet Mr. White commends them in their continued ministry.

    Taking the example set by Jesus and the Holy Spirit in their letters to the seven churches of Asia, it seems to me that a stiff rebuke and a warning against their eminent doom if they do not repent of their drift into doctrinal deviance would be in order.

    Mark Osgatharp
    Wynne, Arkansas

  2. Mark, I am with you. Lets continue the purge with those Baptist churches who have women that speak in church, then those whose members eat meat with blood in it, then those churches whose women members wear no head covering, and then all the churches who shame the word of God by not adhering to the New Testament teachings on slavery. By God, we will fix His church!!!

  3. Stephen,

    Keep it up – you are doing a superb job of making it crystal clear why the Southern Baptists are doing some theological house cleaning. The bottom line is – all rhetoric to the contrary notwithstanding – the so called "moderate" Baptists are actually modernists and don't believe in the authority of the Scriptures at all, Old or New Testaments.

    You do have a good point on the slavery issue. The bitter truth is that the same Baptists who have taken a little bit of a stand against feminism (albeit a mighty weak one) have yet to acknowledge that the Bible is just as clear on the sanctity of lawful slavery as it is on the issue of the subservience of women.

    Mark Osgatharp
    Wynne, Arkansas

  4. Mark,

    I am a member of a Southern Baptist church in so much as we contribute to SBC causes. (There are still some good ones) My membership in a local cooperating congregation will probably continue ….. until the purge reaches into the congregations and begins doing to us what is being done to FBC Decatur.

    God bless you.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This